what is the optimal way to find a parking spot?

A paper in Transportation Science exams how to find a parking space using operations research methodologies. Here, Richard Cassady and John Kobza use applied probability models to identify how to find a “good” parking space according to one of three performance measures:

  1. (Expected) Total walking distance
  2. (Expected) Time to space (ignoring walking distances)
  3. Time to door = expected walking distance + time to find a space

They compare two parking strategies:

  1. Pick a row, closest space (PRCS): The simple strategy of choosing a row close to the parking lot entrance, and picking the closest available space.
  2. Cycling (CYC): a more complicated and aggressive strategy that involves first entering the closest row and parking in the closest of the 20 closest spaces if one is available. If not, the driver proceeds to the next row and chooses the closest of the 40 closest spaces. If one is not available, the driver moves to surrounding rows and selected the closest available space.

parking lot

To visualize how the analysis in this paper is performed, see the figure on the right that shows one of the parking lot geometries considered in the analysis. The analysis is applied to large, Wal-Mart-like parking lots with multiple entrances. I discuss other parking strategies at the end.

The analysis considers six cases (3 performance measures x 2 strategies), and for each, Cassady and Kobza
use a probabilistic approach “to construct general expressions for the performance measure. The
approach treats the decisions made by the driver and the availability of parking spaces as random experiments. By
conditioning on the outcomes of these experiments, the performance of the strategy can be evaluated using the Law of Total Probability.”

Not surprisingly, the PRCS strategy has a lower time to space, since drivers using PRCS find parking spaces fast. Likewise, the CYC has a lower total walking time, since extra driving time finds spaces that are closer to the front door.

Surprisingly, the PRCS strategy performs slightly better when considering the time to door. That is, the time saved finding a parking spot more than makes up for the extra walking time. In a conversation with John Kobza a couple of years ago, he recommended not to cycle and rather to drive to the front of a row. If a close spot is available, take it. Otherwise, park in the closest available spot in the  next row.

Cassady and Kobza acknowledge that the performance measures considered can be misleading in situations when a parking spot is not guaranteed. They also acknowledge that other issues can be incorporated into the analysis (like taking into account the time pushing a shopping cart over to a cart corral).

Cassady and Kobza  implicitly assume that time spent parking and walking are equally weighted in the Time to Door strategy. I use a variant of this strategy when I parallel park on the street when I come to campus that uses unequal weights. Near campus, decent spots are  not guaranteed, so I sometimes have to walk ~10 minutes to my office door. I try not to cycle in the mornings, but I sometimes cycle to shave a little bit off of my walking time if it is raining or I am wearing heels (the brick sidewalks in Richmond are quite uneven).

How do you find a parking spot?

Citation:

A Probabilistic Approach to Evaluate Strategies for Selecting a Parking Space
C. RICHARD CASSADY and JOHN E. KOBZA
Transportation Science , Vol. 32, No. 1 (February 1998), pp. 30-42

Advertisements

9 responses to “what is the optimal way to find a parking spot?

  • prubin73

    PRCS would also appear to minimize the probability of violence over a contested spot. At mass attendance events (e.g., football games), it also minimizes time spent trying to get out of the lot, which may swamp the other two measures.

  • Jeffrey W. Herrmann

    In general, I prefer to find to a spot quickly, because I’d rather walk than drive around the lot (which is wasteful), and I walk fast and need the exercise! At the grocery store, I try to get close to the cart corral to minimize the wasted time putting the cart away. At work, when the weather is bad, I park as close as possible to a building entrance to minimize exposure to the elements, which leads to a longer total walk because that closest entrance is far from my office.

  • Weekly links for September 30 « God plays dice

    […] What is the optimal way to find a parking spot? Share this:TwitterFacebookLike this:LikeBe the first to like this. Categories Uncategorized […]

  • State of Data #123 « Dr Data's Blog

    […] What is the most optimal way to find a parking spot – for lowest total walk-time vs. finding a space fastest […]

  • Somewhere else, part 17 | Freakonometrics

    […] “what is the optimal way to find a parking spot?” http://  punkrockor.wordpress.com/what-is-the-optimal-way-to-find-a-parking-spot/ … by @lamclay  […]

  • Somewhere else, part 16 | Freakonometrics

    […] “what is the optimal way to find a parking spot?”http:// punkrockor.wordpress.com/what-is-the-optimal-way-to-find-a-parking-spot/ … by @lamclay […]

  • ziad

    you know, here in the congested city of Cairo, I can tell you from experience that unless you’re going to park near an event hall or a stadium and a match is about to start, you’re going to wait only a few minutes before a spot near you is freed. That simple. Just the kind of bustling traffic that give you a favorable in/out rate. Add that expectation in the equation and you just might get closer to a statistically sound universal solution.

  • Your Daily Recommended Math – Relatively Prime

    […] to choose the best spot to choose when buying his cake. Thankfully Laura Mclay, who writes the blog Punk Rock Operations Research, had his back or he would probably still be driving around the bakery’s parking […]

  • Your Daily Recommended Math – ACMEScience

    […] to choose the best spot to choose when buying his cake. Thankfully Laura Mclay, who writes the blog Punk Rock Operations Research, had his back or he would probably still be driving around the bakery’s parking […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: