Last week, I made chocolate chip peanut putter cookies except that I substituted sunflower seed butter for peanut butter. It is one of my favorite cookie recipes, and I was looking for a way to use up the rest of my sunflower seed butter (see my post on the nut butter taste-cost tradeoff).
My kids and I ate a few cookies soon after the cookies came out of the oven. A few hours later when the cookies cooled, the insides of the cookies turned a brilliant shade of green. The cookies still tasted fresh and delicious.
An interesting discussion of chemistry ensued. A post on O Chef discusses the chemical reaction that turned my cookies green:
All plants contain chlorogenic acid, mostly in the stems and leaves, but sunflowers also have it in the seeds. A spokeswoman for Red River Commodities says that SunButter does indeed turn cookies and other baked products green as they cool. The solution, she says, is to reduce the amount of baking soda or baking powder in your recipe by almost half, which balances the acidity of the ingredients and keeps them from changing color.
My brother has a PhD in chemistry and offered some feedback. For full disclosure, he is not an expert on the chemistry of cookies, but he knows his stuff.
Well, I hate to disappoint, but I neither know the answer nor any food chemists who may. Luckily the ochef link gives some hints: chlorogenic acid (which is NOT chlorophyll – as on sunbutter’s FAQ section) was implicated and that the pH is important.
I think it is reasonable to assume that oxidation is the cause of the color change as this can be a slow process (thanks to the activation energies, which saves us from burning). Rates of oxidation can be affected by pH, which can explain the effects of adding baking powder, which contains sodium bicarbonate (a base) and lemon juice (an acidic solution) mitigate the color formation. However, lemon juice contains vitamin C, which in addition to being an acid is a strong reducing agent (anti-oxidant). Neither vitamin C nor its oxidation product will absorb light in the visible region and therefore aren’t expected to produce color. Chlorogenic acid will absorb light, but well into the UV region and not the visible region. It is possible that one of its oxidation products does.
But to be honest, I have no idea what all of the ingredients are in sunbutter or how it is processed so I cannot say exactly what is the source of the green color. Chlorogenic acid is a possibility, but there certainly are plenty of other chemicals in the sunbutter that could potentially produce the color as well.
My family and I survived eating the green cookies, so I am confident that we were exposed to an innocent chemical reaction, not botulism or flesh-eating bacteria.
Update on 12/9/2013 from my brother:
I am not an expert in food chemistry, but I can provide some insight. I will address some of your questions below:
Molecular oxygen (O2) is not a good oxidant at the temperatures that we typically encounter, which is great, otherwise we would all catch fire. The reason we don’t is because of the activation energy required for oxygen to burn materials. However, at elevated temperatures (like in a fire or an oven) oxygen will react with many materials, often uncontrollably.
Another way oxygen can react with materials at lower temperatures is by being activated. In the body, this is done by enzymes, which catalyze many reactions that otherwise wouldn’t occur under the conditions (in the case of in the body, often temperature is the limitation). In fact, oxygen is involved in many reduction-oxidation pathways (redox) necessary for life. However, there are some other pathways that can cause deleterious side-effects, namely by forming reactive oxygen species (ROS). Here are a few links, which explain it:
As for what is happening in the cookie, I cannot say for sure. Oxidation is often attenuated by pH. Baking soda contains a weak base, sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO3).
Chlorogenic acid is also a reductant. So while heating in the presence of oxygen, it will likely be oxidized. In the wikipedia article, it mentions that it turns green when oxidized:
It is possible that some oils, or certainly the seeds, which are not refined contain much of the chlorogenic acid (assuming that it is the source of the green color). Changing the pH (by adding acids like lemon juice, or bases like NaHCO3) could change the oxidation potential of the chlorogenic acid and give variable amounts of color in baked products.
Cargill is a major supplier of vegetable oils. They typically refine their oils:
I hope this information helps.
March 22nd, 2012 at 3:50 pm
Given that last week ended with Sr. Paddy’a day, a simpler explanation would be leprechauns.
June 13th, 2012 at 3:15 pm
I am glad my wife found your site. I just made some cookies using spent grain from beer making and used sunflower butter to substitute the peanut for my daughter to be able to eat and like you they looked great coming out of the oven but the next day a lovely shade of green. They taste good still and I am still alive and kicking. new trick for fun party cookies now.Cheers
December 5th, 2012 at 2:47 pm
Thanks for your post! I had the same thing happen with our Christmas cookies, the hershey kiss ones; substituting sunbutter for peanut butter due to allergies, much more relieved that it was the sunbutter and not the crisco(gasp). I began typing in cookies turned green in my google search and your blog came up right away!
May 9th, 2014 at 8:30 am
[…] P.S. This recipe contains the use of sunflower butter, which when cooled, causes the inside of the cookies to turn green. Don’t be alarmed, you have done nothing wrong. All plants contain what’s known as chlorogenic acid, which is found mostly in the stems and leaves, but sunflowers also have it in their seeds. You can read more about it here […]
December 13th, 2014 at 3:44 pm
Baking is not the only way to get the green color. I didn’t finish all of the sunbutter I put on a plate, then let it soak in water overnight (in sink) and the water turned VERY green. My degree is in biochemistry, so I follow most of what your brother said (and did some reading of my own). I am confused how water could oxidize chlorogenic acid?
December 19th, 2015 at 7:10 pm
Ohmygosh I just baked cookes with sunflower butter and they turned totally green!! Thanks for this article I was afraid one didn’t exist for what I had googled!
January 2nd, 2017 at 5:26 am
Just had the same thing happen to me. Cookies turned green from sunbutter in the recipe.
February 28th, 2020 at 9:08 pm
Thank-you for this! I made sunbutter and chickpea cookies tonight and they turned emerald green when they cooled…I was worried I was about to poison my toddler due to some kind of toxic chemical reaction between the chickpeas and sunflower butter, so I was very relieved to read this post 🙂
September 10th, 2020 at 8:32 am
Mines turned green only after I spat them out, the paper towel I spat into turned completely green but the cookie itself was brown. Super weird.
January 10th, 2021 at 8:42 pm
Thank you!! I just had the same experience and promptly started googling. Who knew?!